Clarence Valley CouncilLocal GovernmentLocal News

Mayor: We wanted an investigator, not an administrator

Clarence Valley Council Mayor Peter Johnstone discussing potential state government administration

Mayor: We wanted an investigator, not an administrator

By Tim Howard

Clarence Valley Mayor Peter Johnstone says councillors were hoping for an investigator when they unanimously asked the State Government to examine council governance — not the administrator Local Government Minister Ron Hoenig is now considering appointing.

“We were hoping for an investigator, and instead we get an administrator,” Cr Johnstone said on Saturday.

But the mayor has revealed the possibility of stronger State Government intervention had crossed his mind before Thursday’s unanimous vote.

Cr Johnstone warned councillors during debate on Cr Cristie Yager’s investigation motion that many of the matters they were asking the State Government to examine were actually core responsibilities of the elected governing body.

“We’re asking somebody else to do our job here,” he told Thursday’s extraordinary meeting.

“That’s our job, folks. That’s our job as councillors, and it’s concerning to me that we are effectively abdicating that.”

Speaking on Saturday, Cr Johnstone said he had wondered at the time whether that was something the Minister might also pick up.

“I did wonder if that would be something the minister would pick up on, but I certainly didn’t expect this to happen, and certainly not the day after,” he said.

“I am aware of the full powers of the minister with regard to these sort of things, so it was definitely a possibility.

“I didn’t think it was as high a possibility as it clearly has been. I certainly didn’t expect things to move as fast as they have.”

Mr Hoenig wrote to council on Friday advising he was considering suspending the elected governing body and appointing an interim administrator following council’s unanimous resolution seeking an independent investigation.

The Minister said he reasonably believed an interim administrator might be necessary to restore the council’s “proper and effective functioning”.

No decision to suspend council has been made and councillors have been given an opportunity to make submissions.

Cr Johnstone said the intention behind Cr Yager’s motion had been to obtain independent assistance which could either reassure the community council had a “clean bill of health” or identify particular problems requiring attention.

“That’s what Cristie’s motion was intended to do: to try and reassure people or to find out what are the key issues you need to work on, almost like a clean slate and a fresh broom,” he said.

He also revealed the 9–0 vote did not mean every councillor was completely comfortable with the motion.

“I think several of us were not completely happy with the motion,” Cr Johnstone said.

“But it’s a case that actually we could see the purpose behind it, the reason behind it.”

He said councillors ultimately sought a unanimous position to demonstrate they could debate their differences and move forward together.

“We might as well make it something that’s unanimous as a council,” he said.

“Let’s try and make it unanimous so that the community can see that we will debate the issues, but we’ll actually take it forward and we’ll come up with a joint position.”

Instead, the unanimous resolution produced an almost immediate response from the Minister.

Cr Johnstone said the speed of that response surprised him.

The mayor said he had not been consulted by Mr Hoenig before the letter arrived and, as far as he knew, council had not first been given a performance improvement order.

“It was with remarkable speed,” he said.

Cr Johnstone also agreed the Office of Local Government’s earlier examination of CVC provided important background to the Minister’s latest response.

Earlier this year OLG Deputy Secretary Brett Whitworth conducted a fact-finding exercise following numerous complaints about council but did not recommend major regulatory intervention.

Asked whether that meant the State Government was now faced with deciding whether a stronger response was required, Cr Johnstone said: “I think I agree with you there, Tim.”

“At the end of the day, there was that investigation before, and it didn’t really come out with anything major that council needed to look at,” he said.

But much has happened since.

The past three weeks have included the botched mayoral election, Cr Johnstone’s resignation as mayor and subsequent re-election, and the termination of general manager Laura Black’s contract.

“If you had told me a month ago of everything that would have happened in the last three weeks, I’d have suggested it was fanciful and that you should come up with a more realistic plot,” Cr Johnstone said.

One of his immediate concerns is what possible suspension could mean for the recruitment of CVC’s next general manager.

Cr Johnstone said council wanted to begin that process and believed such an important appointment should be made by the community’s elected representatives.

“We want to start the process of recruiting a new general manager, and I don’t know quite what happens if we’ve been suspended at that point,” he said.

“I think it’s right that the community has an opportunity, through their representatives as councillors, to get the opportunity to select the general manager.”

Cr Johnstone said he intended to make his own submission to the Minister and hoped Tuesday’s extraordinary meeting would produce a joint council submission arguing the elected governing body remained capable of running the council.

“I’m guessing our submission will be accepted and the minister will take on board what we have to say — that this isn’t really what we intended, and that actually we do have the capacity to handle council because we do,” he said.

“But at the end of the day, that’ll be down to the minister.”

Council will meet at 4.30pm on Tuesday to consider its response.

For Cr Johnstone, the task is now very different from the one councillors thought they had set themselves on Thursday.

They asked the State Government for help investigating their council.

The mayor suspected the Minister might see something more fundamental in that request.

He just didn’t expect to find out the following day.

Kyogle News, Richmond Valley News, Clarence Valley News, Lismore News, Ballina News, Byron News, Tweed News, Gold Coast News, Coffs Harbour News

Related posts

CORBETT (nee CLIBBENS), Violet Myrtle Death Notice

JeffG

10-Minute French Onion Chicken Rice Bake

News Desk

Urgent action needed to address shocking rates of suicide among homeless youth