Police called to council meeting
By Tim Howard
A protester whose actions required police to intervene in the latest Clarence Valley Council meeting has vowed to ramp up community civil disobedience.
A prominent council critic, Craigh McNeill, began interjecting during debate at the council meeting last Thursday in Grafton, causing Mayor Ray Smith to adjourn the meeting while police were called to restore order.
The protest occurred when the first item of business on the agenda was called, a Mayoral Minute dealing with the performance review of the general manager, Laura Black, which recommended she receive a 2.5% pay rise.
The protesters began calling out, objecting to the recommendation in the Mayoral Minute and making claims about Ms Black’s performance since she became general manager in 2022.
Mr McNeill and two other protesters left the chambers escorted by police.
Mr McNeill is the administrator for a Facebook page called The Clarence Forum, on which he has posted many criticisms of the council and its staff.
After the protest, a video was posted on it of Mr McNeill and the two others talking to a police officer outside the council chambers.
The police said no charges had been laid and the protesters were allowed to leave after giving assurances they would not return to the meeting.
But Mr McNeill has promised the protests would continue and has written to Cr Smith warning that there would be a protest at the next council meeting calling for a “no confidence motion” in the general manager.
“As part of our preparations, I am completing a Notice of Intention to Hold a Public Assembly to ensure safety and minimise impacts on the surround area,” he wrote.
“Could you please advice on the number of supporters you would need to see in order to consider moving forward with a ‘no confidence motion’?”
In the post containing the video of his interaction with police, Mr McNeill

A Grafton police officer speaks with one of the protesters, Craigh McNeill, outside the Clarence Valley Council chambers in Grafton last Thursday, after polce were called to the chambers to deal with a disturbance during the meeting. The image has been taken from a video posted on social media by Mr McNeill.
“Today, I stood up at a Clarence Valley Council meeting to address serious concerns about misleading information being provided by Ms Black to councillors, the state government, and the public,” the post read.
“Instead of being heard, I was silenced. The police were called, and I was told that I had created ‘fear and alarm’.
“Is this what democracy looks like in our community?
“When we speak out against potential wrongdoing, are we to be met with intimidation and accusations of causing fear?
“It seems that questioning authority is now a threat to public order.”
Cr Smith said he was pleased Mr McNeill had decided to go through the proper channels of advising him and the police that he was organising a public assembly at the next council meeting.
But he disagreed completely with the substance of Mr McNeill’s criticism of the general manager.
“I would refute completely any claims of misconduct by the general manager,” he said.
“And I won’t be supporting his request for a vote of no confidence in the general manager.
“Only last Thursday I moved a mayoral minute which endorsed the performance of the general manager and recommended a pay increase for her.”
Cr Smith said the decision had been reached during confidential session, but confirmed the vote had been tight, 5-4 in favour of his Mayoral Minute.
He also confirmed that two of the four councillors on the performance review panel had voted against the pay rise for the general manager.
The panel consisted of Cr Smith, deputy mayor Cr Greg Clancy, Cr Cristie Yager and Cr Debrah Novak.
Cr Smith said the during the process of the performance review panel meeting, there had been a consensus on the performance of the general manager.
There had been discussion of the process of the performance review panel and to give it some “tweaks” to reduce generic content and add more specific, localised performance indicators.
On social media Cr Debrah Novak said the protesters achieved nothing and councillors “had another cup of tea” while police spoke to the them.
“The three people who sought their five seconds of FB fame achieved zero,” she wrote.
“The police were called not because they were protesting, not because they were yelling at us, but because they refused to leave the chamber so that the meeting could continue with the important business of the day.”
Once the councillors returned to the meeting, the Mayoral Minute was moved into confidential session, on a motion from Cr Greg Clancy.
But some uncertainty remains about the decision as both the recording of the meeting and the minutes of it have not been released.
Cr Smith said he understood there had been some technical issues with the recording, but the minutes would be available by Tuesday.
For more local news, click here.